Licensing

Why Music Licensing for Games Still Needs a New Business Model

Vickie Nauman’s account of buyouts, performing rights and Beat Saber points to a more useful question than catalog size: what does the game actually need?

3 Nov 2026

The story

Speaking at Music Ally’s Publishing Summit, CrossBorderWorks CEO Vickie Nauman describes a market that does not behave like film and television synchronization or a streaming service. In Music Ally’s November 2 report, she says most games want relatively small collections, often 10–50 songs. That is her professional assessment, not a measured distribution of every developer’s requirements.

A selective synchronization deal clears music for a defined game use. A catalog-wide arrangement can serve a different purpose when users choose music across a much broader collection. Neither is automatically the better model: repertoire, territory, duration, downloadable content and the way music interacts with gameplay determine what needs clearing.

The sound recording and the underlying composition are separate rights. Permission from the owner of a recording does not automatically clear the song. A developer using an existing recording needs appropriate permissions for both; commissioning new music changes the counterparties, but does not make the contract’s scope irrelevant.

Nauman describes commissioned scores and upfront buyouts as an established alternative to licensing artist recordings. An upfront fee is a payment structure; the contract determines whether it grants a limited license or transfers rights. An advance plus revenue share instead puts money on the table initially and can create continuing payments once the agreed advance is recouped. No one structure guarantees better returns without the actual terms and performance.

Her Imagine Dragons / Beat Saber example makes that distinction concrete. Nauman recounts convincing a reluctant publisher to accept an advance-and-revenue-share deal. According to her account, the advance was recouped within the first quarter and royalty payments followed. It is a case study from a participant in the negotiation, not a published benchmark for other rhythm games.

Public-performance rights remain another layer. Nauman says she has worked with collecting societies over four years toward structures that do not require artists or songwriters to leave their performing rights organization. The rights involved depend on use and jurisdiction. Her reported support from societies should not be mistaken for a universally available or universally adopted solution.

Artist-driven music can connect a game to an existing community, creating possibilities beyond background score: performance, interactive participation and commerce. Nauman describes this as an experimental stage. Her belief that artist music can outperform commissioned music is a proposition for developers to test, not an established industry-wide result.

She also reports resistance to generative music among developers and players she encounters, while anticipating artist, songwriting and production tools. Those observations are not a representative survey. The practical issue remains whether a tool and its rights position fit the experience, rather than assuming AI music is either an inevitable substitute or absent from every game.

Why it matters

The opportunity is to reduce clearance friction while aligning the incentives of developers, recording owners and songwriters. Small, well-chosen repertoires can be commercially meaningful when the permissions and payment structure fit the product. Catalog access alone does not solve performing rights, implementation or the question of whether audiences actually engage with the music.

Related coverage

The Music + Gaming Brief

The information layer for music and gaming.