Industry

AI Music Copyright Disputes Expand: An Alphabet Suit and Separate OpenAI Briefs

A shareholder’s allegations about Google’s training practices and music organizations’ fair-use arguments belong to different proceedings, not a settled rule for game music.

3 Nov 2026

Allegations and legal arguments: no liability finding

The story

Music Ally’s November 3 roundup links to Music Business Worldwide’s report of a shareholder derivative complaint filed by Phil Rosen on October 30 in federal court in Chicago. The report identifies Sundar Pichai and 12 other Alphabet directors and executives as defendants. A derivative suit is brought on the company’s behalf; it is not the same as a copyright-owner lawsuit seeking royalties for particular songs.

According to MBW’s account of the complaint, Rosen alleges an unlawful strategy involving copyrighted works and voices, including recordings, compositions and lyrics allegedly used for Lyria. Those are allegations, not findings of infringement or established liability. Music Ally also identifies Mulan and MusicLM in the reported training dispute.

A separate development concerns the consolidated copyright litigation involving OpenAI and Microsoft, including claims by the New York Times and authors. MBW reports that RIAA, NMPA, ASCAP, BMI and other music organizations filed a proposed supporting brief on October 30 opposing the defendants’ fair-use position. These organizations are not parties seeking damages in that case.

MBW separately describes a request by the Human Consent Foundation, joined by CAA and Irving Azoff’s Music Artists Coalition, to submit a brief about scalable licensing. A request to submit a brief, a proposed brief, and a court’s decision are not interchangeable. Neither filing establishes that a court has accepted its arguments.

For game developers considering AI music, the commercial issue is provenance, permissions and the contractual protection offered by a tool provider. Future judgments or settlements could influence those terms. The proceedings reported here have not themselves created a binding new game-music licensing rule or settled the broader fair-use question.

Why it matters

Music’s rights organizations are entering disputes that extend beyond music-only models because the legal reasoning could influence later licensing negotiations. That makes these cases relevant to game audio procurement, while leaving an important boundary intact: advocacy and allegations are not court rulings, and different models, uses and agreements need separate assessment.

Related coverage

The Music + Gaming Brief

The information layer for music and gaming.